Results vs Development: Fred Lipka on the Biggest Mistake in US Coaching

This week on the MSC Podcast, we sit down with Fred Lipka, Technical Director of Youth Development at Major League Soccer. Few people have influenced the MLS academy landscape more over the past decade, and this conversation goes deep into what’s working, what’s broken, and what needs to change in US player and coach development.

Fred shares powerful insight on why he believes American soccer has been “built upside down,” why the weekly rhythm should always be five days to develop, one day to perform, and why judging coaches solely by results is holding back both player development and coaching standards.

We dive into:

• The real purpose of youth competition

• Why US soccer over-teaches with big numbers

• The lack of 1v1 wingers and aggressive fullbacks

• Touch limits, robotic players, and constraints-led training

• Relative age effect and selecting the “big kids” too early

• Why domestic coaches should stop feeling inferior

• Inside the MLS–French Federation (EFCL) course

• The rise of US talent and why Europe is watching

• How MLS academies are building community, not isolation

Fred’s honesty in this episode is exceptional, and his clarity on how to optimize the individual player — not just the team — is something every coach can learn from.

You can listen to the full interview below. Please 'like' and subscribe if you enjoy it!

This episode is proudly sponsored by Zone 14 Coaching, a company built by coaches for coaches. Zone 14 creates high-quality player and coach journals that bring more intention, reflection, and clarity to the season. Grounded in proven learning science and real coaching experience, their NextGen journals help coaches plan smarter sessions, help players think deeper about their performances, and strengthen the connection between the training ground and the game.

If you want to develop adaptable, reflective, growth-minded players, Zone 14 Coaching offers one of the simplest and most powerful tools you can add to your environment. Check them out at zone14coaching.com.